Anya Kamenetz is the author of four books on education, and for eight years covered education for NPR. Currently, she speaks, writes, and thinks about thriving and caring for others on a rapidly changing planet, topics that she covers in her newsletter, The Golden Hour, and a focus of her work with the Aspen Institute and the Climate Mental Health Network. She’s a graduate of Yale, a New Orleans native, and now a resident of Brooklyn where she lives with her husband and their two children.
Her forthcoming book, Falling In Love With The World Again, is about how to cope with the world right now.
Joining Catherine and Anya’s conversation are three experts focused on education and climate change: Emily Fano, Director of Climate Education at NWF.org and leader of the coalition Climate & Resilience Education Task Force; Yadana Desmond, Executive Director of STEMteachersNYC.org; and Carolyn McGrath, co-author of An Educator’s Guide to Climate Emotions, teacher at Hopewell Valley Regional School District (NJ), and a guest on a previous episode of Bridging the Carbon Gap.
Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify
Anya Kamenetz 00:05
My relationship with my kids has deepened through the work that I’ve done to try to come to terms with my own feelings. It’s very hard having children these days when we don’t know what the world’s going to look like in 2045.
Catherine Du 00:24
Welcome back to another episode of Bridging the Carbon Gap. My name is Catherine Du, and I’m a sophomore at Hunter College High School. Today, we’re speaking with Anya Kamenetz, an award-winning journalist, former NPR correspondent, and advisor to the Climate Mental Health Network.
Anya has spent two decades covering education, and her new book, Falling in Love with the World Again, asks a question most of us avoid: What do we do with how climate change makes us feel? In this conversation, recorded live with educators on the call, she explains why fear, sadness, and anger can become sources of strength, and why the best way to talk about climate is to start by listening, and what schools, parents, and young people can do next.
Catherine Du
My first question was: Tell us more about your journey from Yale to your place in the climate movement now.
Anya Kamenetz 00:53
I think that Yale was a place that, first of all, started my journey in journalism. So I came in kind of with more of a creative writing interest, and I ended up joining the New Journal, which is a long form magazine, which kind of had aspirations of more literary nonfiction type journalism, which was fun for me. But I got very interested in journalism because of the way I could, you know, combine my interest in social justice and changing the world with the craft of writing.
Catherine Du 01:12
Where are your Yale classmates now, especially maybe those who were in that magazine, and how do you see their perspectives on climate differ from yours.
Anya Kamenetz 01:22
Yeah, that’s a really interesting question. I remain good friends with a handful of my classmates, and I would say that they are all world changing, but in different lanes. I would say, for the most part, I think what you can see is that climate competes with other concerns for people’s attention and people’s energy, and I think that’s been true for sure of my classmates.
Catherine Du 02:23
You said that climate competes with other issues for people’s attention. How do you think that that has impacted why other people are choosing some issues to specialize in than others?
Anya Kamenetz 02:37
Yeah, I mean, this has really become kind of the bullseye of what I’m interested in writing about, because I think that climate is so overwhelming and even frightening, and people don’t always feel the sense of efficacy that they can actually make a difference working on something that’s so big, and particularly when it requires us to take on kind of the powers that be as far as economically and politically in our in our life, so I I think I feel like, and that’s one that’s one answer.
Another possible answer that provides maybe a little more direction to how we could change it is that certainly when I was growing up in the ’90s, there were a lot of people who tended to speak about environmental issues in a way that was focusing more on the non-human world, and I think that’s very understandable, but it may not be as top of mind. So many people have a natural tendency to want to privilege the interests of humans above other species or above natural systems that are more abstract.
And I actually remember having this debate as a high school student with a friend of mine, kind of a precocious debate. But I was in my environmental club in high school, and she was more of a social justice type kid. And she was like, you know, when there’s children starving, why? What you have to focus on is reducing poverty and, you know, increasing economic growth, and you can’t focus so much on, you know, the live animal welfare, for example, or saving the rainforest. And so in the ’90s, it was more common, I think, to split these issues up into splinters. You know, people talked about save the whale, save the rainforest, save this particular species from logging, and there were reasons that it was done that way. But it didn’t always, you know, enable people to see the connections amongst these issues. And I think it’s far more effective and more accurate to talk about climate justice and the way that the interests of the human and the non-human world really coincide.
Catherine Du 04:31
How do you think that people should talk to each other about climate change as opposed to something like the reference of wild animals?
Anya Kamenetz 04:39
You know, I think first of all, there is a time and a place to share our love of wild animals or the non-human world. I think we all have an innate love of you know living things, biophilia. So that can definitely be an effective way to talk to people about species that they connect with that they care about. But you know, asking that question about what’s the best way to talk to people about climate change? I really think the best way is to start by listening. So thinking about what you can learn about people, about what they care about, what’s top of mind for them at that moment, and that will really help you figure out the entry points into the conversation.
So you know, understanding, for example, you know, it could be about their heating bills this winter, right? And we can talk about energy efficiency. It could be about worrying about a flood or extreme weather, and we can talk about making our cities safer. Or maybe people have the bandwidth to kind of worry about clean air and clean water for their kids. So there’s always there’s the thing about the good and the bad of climate change. It is all so pervasive. It connects to so many different things. So if we can build our knowledge, we can help find those entry points to connect with people.
Catherine Du 05:47
Just to pivot a little bit, in your Substack, the Golden Hour, you often describe how motherhood has shaped you. What would you say to parents starting to learn more about the climate crisis and wondering about the implications for them and their children?
Anya Kamenetz 05:59
Yeah, it’s a wonderful question. I think that being a parent is such a huge opportunity to connect with your own empathy, with your community, and with your love for the future. So you know, when you’re a parent, you really are invested in a world that’s going to be there after you’re gone. That’s kind of the deal. And so, what I really advise parents to try to do is to make sure that they have a support structure for talking about their own feelings about climate change. Because a lot of times, you know, kids will surprise us with a really tough question, or even feels like an accusation or an anxiety that they have about the future. And if you haven’t done your own internal work, you’re going to be caught off guard to answer that.
So you know, I really do advise parents if they’re asking this question, it’s an excellent indication that this is maybe coming up for them for their kids. And so you know, make sure that you have people to talk to about these issues. And I think the best place to find that is you know you can go to a climate cafe, you can join an organization, and not only get involved in talking about climate change, but also involved in solutions.
Catherine Du 07:04
Your past four books have largely focused on the education system. How do you think the education system and the climate crisis are connected, if at all?
Anya Kamenetz 07:14
You know, I love this question, and I see that there’s people on the call that have really deep, powerful knowledge about this question. The climate crisis is a huge challenge for our schools, and it is a huge opportunity for our schools to evolve and become more relevant and more grounded in providing an education that’s actually powerful and useful. So, in terms of the challenge, I mean, we can point to anything from extreme weather that’s interrupting classrooms, extreme heat that’s making it harder for students to concentrate, the need to update our school buildings and infrastructure, and then the curriculum that is just now starting to expand and introduce the basic facts of climate change, as well as solutions. And there’s an enormous need to train teachers to be comfortable in delivering that information, as well as I believe the emotional impact of this information.
This is not neutral information. It’s going to have an impact on students as they learn it. The opportunity here is when we start thinking about the climate crisis, and I really think about it as the center of something called the poly crisis. So we have this time of multiple intersecting, complicated crises, and the flip side of that is multiple solutions. So, in order to have good climate change conversations or education, you really need to have systems thinking. You need to have integration of different topics, and the thing that I mentioned before, which is that there’s an entry point for absolutely every person. So, really good climate change education is education that allows students to put them in the driver’s seat to be thinking about the kind of society and world that they want to live in, and how different disparate ideas connect to each other, and that is a wonderful position to be in when it comes to education. Another dimension or way of thinking about this that I find so just inspiring and relevant is thinking about traditional and indigenous ecological forms of knowledge. So you know, we come from many different traditional societies that, of necessity, lived much closer to living systems and had a much deeper understanding of living systems, and a lot of that knowledge has been implicit, and it was taught, you know, in through cultural transmission.
But schools now have an opportunity to introduce that kind of knowledge and information, and you know, allow students the opportunity to learn directly from nature to learn about living systems, how they intersect, and to learn through traditional cultures, and really have a deep place-based type of education. And I think that’s just really appealing. You know, I’m excited about that opportunity or that possibility.
Catherine Du 09:56
Do you think there’s any places that are like role models or good examples of this sort of education structure, or no?
Anya Kamenetz 10:04
Yeah, I mean, I think we can see it here and there. You know, there’s a lot of issues in education where things kind of are like they’re case studies, but then they don’t necessarily spread. But I did, you know, I visited Fannie Lou Hamer High School, for example, in the Bronx, where there’s a teacher who’s developed a whole course around education, environmental justice, and it’s very place-based, so it’s about what’s you know the the the challenges of that neighborhood. I had a chance to visit New Mexico public schools. There’s a whole unit where students get to visit the pueblo and learn from traditional educators about the legal system that they’re part of there. So those are two examples that come to mind.
Catherine Du 10:49
The UK National Emergency Briefing Campaign had messages that people should be trusted with the truth about major risks that affect their lives, and history suggests that profound shifts often appear unrealistic until shortly before they happen. To what extent do you think this is true?
Anya Kamenetz 11:06
Well, I definitely believe that people need to be trusted with the truth. I think that that’s something that we, many of us collectively, lived through during the COVID pandemic, was the dangers of having public health messaging that assumed that people couldn’t handle the nuance or the uncertainty, and that had a real backfiring effect where people lost their trust in scientific authorities. So I think that there is a need for communication with the public that is clear and honest, and it also has to come from a foundation of trust.
I think that schools are a place where that can happen. You know, in my experience, people do trust their public schools, and people tend to trust their teachers more so than a lot of other authorities. So I think there’s opportunities there. The second question is that things seem impossible until they become real. Yeah, I mean that’s something that is a unique capacity of young people. I think so. I don’t know how much you’re following the demonstrations in France right now, but there is this outpouring, right, of rage, but also visionary excitement. And one of the slogans of that protest is, “I’ve seen the future and we won.” So you know the idea of things seeing the impossible until they come to pass. I think it kind of requires people that don’t necessarily remember all the time that we spent failing, and people who are kind of starting from scratch to say why can’t it be different?
Catherine Du 12:37
How much do you think that applies to climate education and like climate shifts and adaptations?
Anya Kamenetz 12:44
I think it can be. I mean, I’ll say this. I think we’re witnessing it happening in terms of clean energy. So the way the clean energy has ballooned and mushroomed over the last five to 10 years alone has been completely astonishing. And I think it’s under a lot of people’s radar because it’s not something that people check; it’s not on the top of the news. You know, if we follow the news closely, we can see it. And even then, in the last, you know, since February, since the war in Iran started, there’s been an even faster turn towards batteries, electric vehicles, solar installations. So, the growth of clean energy has continuously broken through projections. It’s just continuously violated projections and gotten higher and higher, faster and faster, cheaper and cheaper. And so, you know, it hasn’t been. It’s been outside of anybody’s prediction.
Catherine Du 13:34
Back to your Substack. If you could tell us more about the process you go through to write articles in Substack and other places, and maybe like how you follow the news.
Anya Kamenetz 13:43
Yeah, I mean, I started the Substack to kind of first of all like see if anybody else was out there who thought about things and looked at things the same way that I did. So it was really amazing for me to be living in a time when I could start start my own platform and just kind of see and not have to ask for anyone’s permission, and the process that I go through is really a combination of what’s on my mind and on my heart, like what’s literally keeping me up at night, and what I think is going to be useful or helpful. So I start with kind of, it could be you know something that’s in the news, something that’s come up in my life, usually a combination of the two, and I sort of I look at my own reactions to it, and then I try to see what I can find from research or from reading or from other people that helps me understand better what’s happening. Helps me understand my own reactions to it, and that’s usually what a Golden Hour post includes.
Catherine Du 14:36
I know you recently announced that your forthcoming book, “Falling in Love with the World Again: Finding Your Way When Everything Feels Broken.” will be published by Bloomsbury. Congratulations. What would you like us to know about the book and your journey writing it?
Anya Kamenetz 14:51
Yeah, absolutely. (Thank you, Emily.) I wrote the book over a period of almost it’s going to be almost five years, and it really is a record of my own personal evolution into understanding how important the emotional dimension is when it comes to navigating the world around us and the crises that we’re in. So, I started with kind of a deep question, which gets back to your initial question to me, which is, climate change is a really big deal. Why don’t people talk about it? Why don’t people face how they’re feeling about it?
I know that people are feeling a lot of things about it, but they’re not talking about how they feel, and that can feel make you feel kind of crazy, like the disconnect between this very clear and scary present and future danger and the absence from everyday conversations, so I really started. That was my starting point, and I delved into, okay, the thing that’s making people not want to think about this is denial, overwhelm, and behind that denial, there are a lot of scary, there’s fear, there is sadness, and there’s anger, and the thing is that feelings are not scary inherently.
Like I, I have two kids. The kids went to preschool. In preschool, we learned to talk about big feelings. We learned about social and emotional skills. The feelings are something that are normal, and big feelings are normal. And so, kind of taking that very childish wisdom into the grown-up world and saying, you know what, I don’t have to hide from the world or hide from what’s happening. I can actually learn to process my feelings about what’s happening. And on the other side of those feelings is actually something really, really valuable because your feelings about the world are showing you that you’re connected to the world, and they are showing you what you really care about and what you care about enough to fight for, and so when you stop being afraid of the feelings themselves, they can end up being more resource of strength.
And so for now, whenever something really scary happens in the world, I have a, I can get past my shutdown and my overwhelm, and I can get into a space where I can feel like my feelings are okay, and I can process them with a friend. I can come up with the next action step, and I can know more than anything that this is something I want to pay attention to. I don’t want to turn away from, and the outcome of that is that I spend less time trying to bury my feelings, which means I spend less time doom scrolling. I spend less time stress eating. I spend less time not getting sleep, and I spend more time doing the things that I want to do, which is also like enjoying my life without feeling like there’s a deep dark cloud over it because I feel like I’ve dealt with the reasons that I feel that way.
Catherine Du 17:36
How do you see the book fit into the broader climate conversation?
Anya Kamenetz 17:41
Um, I hope that it is complementary because I think that the climate conversation is amazing. There’s so many wonderful leaders that I learned so much from, and I think sometimes there’s a little bit of a circular conversation that goes on where people are maybe scolding each other for having the wrong feeling, like oh, you need to turn your anxiety into action, or you need to look at the positives, or you shouldn’t tell other people what to do. That’s another one, and it’s like just to understand, just to get some basic emotional literacy, and say oh, people are coming from different parts of the feeling wheel at different times, and you can understand where someone is. So, like when you asked me at the beginning of the conversation, what’s the best way to talk to people about climate change? And I was like, well, the best way is to listen to them first, right? So then it’s actually a conversation. I feel like a little bit of that emotional literacy. And there’s been, you know, there’s. I’m not going at this alone. I’m standing on the shoulders of a whole field of people in climate mental health who are urging the rest of the world in terms of activists and change makers to get a little emotional literacy and get a little bit of psychological grounding and do their own work as well? Because I think another part of this is that activists get very burnt out and they are oftentimes running on fumes. And so within our social movements, you know, the people that are doing the most important work to change the world. They’re sometimes themselves are hanging by a thread, so encouraging that kind of self care and that emotional insight, I think, is another big part of this.
Catherine Du 19:09
Back to the question about talking to people about climate change, and you mentioned that listening is a good step. So, how do you think things like legislation and mandates play a role in starting climate conversations and shaping public climate education?
Anya Kamenetz 19:24
You know, we live in a systemic world with bureaucracy and rules and laws and policies, and so change making those are the levers of change making. So if people start talking about climate change solely because of state requirements, then that’s good. That’s a conversation that wasn’t happening before. I believe that policy change comes hand in hand with cultural change. So you know these are things that are going to continue to have to happen. Just because there’s a state mandate doesn’t mean that we’re going to automatically have you know the climate based education of our dreams. But it’s a worthy effort and it needs to continue on all fronts. I think.
Catherine Du 20:02
Why do you think volunteers should do climate education work, if at all?
Anya Kamenetz 20:08
Why do we think volunteers should do climate education work?
Catherine Du 20:11
Yes.
Anya Kamenetz 20:12
What do you mean by volunteers?
Catherine Du 20:14
Like someone who chooses to donate their time rather than someone who is paid to do so, or do you think there’s like no difference?
Anya Kamenetz 20:23
Are they choosing whether to volunteer for climate education versus something else? Or I’m not sure. I totally understand the question.
Catherine Du 20:33
Um, I think there’s a concept I think called deep canvassing, where people like go to places and have conversations with people, and then try to talk more about a specific issue. So, do you think that this should be more of like a volunteer-based activity, something that’s more mandated, or do you think there’s another systemic way to advance climate education?
Anya Kamenetz 20:57
I see. I mean, I like the idea of having climate education be in our state education laws, I think that people should be learning about it from you know pre K onward. In terms of voter education or public education or public public information education, sure. I mean that there is, I think there’s a lot to be gained from doing the kind of deep canvassing where you really help people understand how what they care about is related to the climate, because the nice thing about climate change is that it relates to everybody.
Catherine Du
Another question I had was a bit more of a paradox in our city, where we’re spending like billions, I think hundreds of billions of dollars for resilience, but leaving very little money for dialogue. And I’m sure that you know that a lot of this billions of dollars of climate resilience goes to protecting Manhattan and protecting the banks that fund fossil fuels. I was curious what your thoughts on this sort of paradox was in terms of climate resilience without much dialog or climate education.
Anya Kamenetz
Yeah, I think this is a really important proposal and idea because resilience comes first and foremost from people’s knowledge and relationships. A striking example of this is how in Bangladesh they were able to reduce deaths from flooding through a campaign of teaching women how to swim, because traditionally women had not had the cultural opportunity to learn how to swim. So you know they did that not by changing the physical infrastructure, but they did it by changing people’s knowledge. So I think that there is a huge role for resilience in personal resilience in education. Not only because it’ll help people prioritize climate intervention, but also because it can be a form of climate intervention itself, and I think the neglect of the human dimension.
You know, we can see a parallel of it with the way that we’re not necessarily, you know, taking care of the humans that do all kinds of work. We don’t take care of the humans that do education work, for example, or childcare work, or or climate movement work as well. So you can see, you can think of education and public information and investment as a human dimension, the social capital dimension of the transformation that we need to have.
Catherine Du 23:13
Circling a bit back to your Yale classmates and climate conversation in general, how do you think, like teachers, universities, and other institutions of education can help make climate conversations start, even when there is no legislation.
Anya Kamenetz 23:28
Universities have a huge role to play in fostering public conversation, especially when you have researchers being in conversation with students and with the public and with activists, and kind of, and as well as cultural voices. So I think that there’s a lot. There’s a role to play for artists, musicians, and other types of people in the humanities to to really bring this stuff top of mind.
Catherine Du 23:51
Why do you think climate conversations did start at Yale and other institutions since they’ve had climate information since like the 1900s.
Anya Kamenetz 24:03
I mean the, so Yale is the home for the Program on Climate Communication. So I know that they’ve been of interest to people there for a long time. I feel like in a lot of institutions like Yale, there’s a little bit of a hierarchy of people’s concerns, not only even a hierarchy, but like a siloing.
So you know, when I was there, really the conversation that had to do with climate change was in the silo of environmental science and earth science, and it was it didn’t really there wasn’t a lot of crossover, and then there was there were people involved in social social activism and direct service work, and a little bit in policy work. There was energy and environment, and there was you know so there’s and there’s ethics ethics, politics, and economics. So like different departments, right? So it’s like departmental silos, and then the arts people were like in a whole other realm. They weren’t necessarily doing cultural conversation, so it didn’t have the place-based like community building that you might see around different kinds of, for example, I often draw the parallel with conversations about race and ethnicity and justice, right?
So when you, if you have, for example, like we had a Jewish Hillel. We had a Black Students Union. We had an Asian American Students Union. Those are places where people come together and they talk about, okay, this is my identity. This is what it means to me. This is the broader political landscape. This is what it means on the world stage. And now you’re having a conversation that’s personal and political at the same time. And there’s a place for it. And then there’s cultural stuff that comes in. You know, there’s community building stuff that comes in, but that’s not how we talk about climate change. We don’t, we don’t organize it in that fashion, so we don’t have a hub where people can have these kinds of conversations. I think that’s starting to change. I think there’s people doing all kinds of rituals, community building, climate cafes, good grief network workshops, climate mental health network workshops. So there are people who are starting to make these spaces for this conversation now. But it’s been a long time coming.
Catherine Du 26:07
What do you see in the future and the future for students and educators in the climate crisis?
Anya Kamenetz 26:13
I mean, I think that this is going to be increasingly top of mind. But I was so, and I would love to start to see more evolution of the different systems that make schools come together. So, you know, I was involved over Climate Week. I was involved in a conversation, Climate Mental Health Network, where I’m an advisor, is working on a project post LA fires, and they’re trying to figure out. First of all, we’re just identifying the needs, right? The long tail of mental health needs that come after a disaster like that, and not just the people who are directly affected, but also the broader community who have, you know, experienced the disruptions of these fires.
And nobody really owns the climate mental health impacts of a disaster like that, especially when they’re long term. There are so many different people that a young person or family might interact with over the course of their lives, like whether it’s social workers, whether it’s somebody at the school, whether it’s you know a faith-based organization or an after-school group or a mentoring group, and so there’s a need to bring people together and make a holistic view of what climate mental health is, like what is how is this impacting people as humans, and then as a school.
I mean, I have a really good friend who’s a superintendent, right? When you think about how climate change impacts her job as a superintendent, there is extreme weather in terms of the physical school building. There’s her energy costs and the need to be prepared, right, for heat waves or for floods. There is the climate anxiety that students might be bringing into her community, and then there is the need to prepare for climate-based careers and climate-based futures within her state.
So those are all intersecting across so many different things, right? There’s physical plan infrastructure, there’s curriculum, there’s hiring, and there’s student services and student social emotional skills, so it really requires again a systems thinker. And my hope is that we start to see more and more evolution in terms of how we’re training and preparing people to be leaders in a future that is going to be coming at us from all these different directions at once.
Catherine Du 28:17
In an ideal world, if we’re on a finite planet, what do you think people’s concepts of success should be, and what’s your concept of success?
Anya Kamenetz 28:26
Such a beautiful question. Can I turn it back on you for a second? How do you think about that? What’s your aspiration?
Catherine Du 28:34
Oh, I actually don’t know. I feel like a lot of what I’ve been doing in high school is just trying to try a lot of things and figure out what works out within fighting for climate justice. Um, I feel like the idea of what happens if we’re successful in stopping the climate crisis hasn’t really occurred to me yet, I guess, because it seems like such this broad looming issue that has so many levels and is so intertwined with our political system on so many levels. From fossil fuel, what’s it called? Like polluter handouts. I think in New York was a big problem. How the energy system is like how there’s like gas in almost every kitchen in New York City, and also just how like how deeply entrenched our system is in an in a way that’s like very unsustainable in the long term, so I feel like such massive, profound systems are sort of, back to the UK national briefing, it’s hard to think about until it happens. So I guess I’m still figuring that part out.
Anya Kamenetz 29:53
How did you come to be so passionate about this?
Catherine Du 29:57
I learned first about climate change in elementary school. So I think COVID was very important in this because during COVID, like we didn’t have to commute to school and stuff, so I had a lot of time at home. And I read a lot of books, including I think like a 17-hour audio book, *The Climate Book* by Greta Thunberg, that really went into how deep the climate crisis was, which just started like as a question, and then exploded into like an obsession, I suppose, during COVID. And after that, it’s just been stuck with me for a long time.
Anya Kamenetz 30:33
Wow, that’s so interesting. Thank you for sharing that. I mean, I think COVID was probably pretty formative for me too, in terms of bringing this top of mind. And certainly, what it showed us all is that things can change overnight, right? If humanity detects a threat large enough, and that we can engage in incredible collective action, if in fact we are able to coordinate and there’s a will, it also shows the brittleness of these systems at the same time.
So when you ask what aspiration looks like in this climate challenge world, I think the answer is hidden in the question, right? Because this notion of you know we have a finite planet, we have to abandon the dream of infinite growth. And for decades and decades, we’ve been in this time of real exponential growth in terms of not in terms of biodiversity, of course, but in terms of the number of humans on the planet and the amount of abstractly considered wealth that we created, which oftentimes just means extracting resources and transforming them into other forms. Right, a lot of which is waste, a lot of which is slop, a lot of which is useless.
And while we’ve created an incredible vision of abundance and convenience, we’ve also removed ourselves from the world with all these layers of abstraction and mediation, and you know the losses and the gains are both very high, and so you know there are things about this growth society, what Joanna Macy calls the industrial growth society, that I love and don’t want to give back. I believe in universal human rights. Every single person having their own little bit of you know autonomy and sense of future. And previous generations didn’t have that to the same extent.
Even my own mother’s generation didn’t have her full human rights right when she was born in 1950, so that’s progress. I think medically we’ve made progress. We’ve made progress in terms of human knowledge. So there are things I want to keep in terms of the concept of progress, but in terms of constant growth up into the right forever, whether it’s population or whether it’s what we call you know now we’re labeling GDP, that has to end, and so what replaces it, I think, is a, I would love to see a lot of moral innovation. You know, I’d love to see new ways of distributing wealth and distributing the gains and reducing inequality and better and better ways of relating to each other that reduce violence, that reduce the need for incarceration.
That reduces the need to take away people’s freedom, so that we can deal with each other with justice. I think all of that is very attainable. Like, we can see examples of where it happens. We can see what it looks like to live in a safe neighborhood, to drink clean water, to breathe clean air. These things exist now. It’s really about making them more available to more people.
Catherine Du 33:23
So there was an op-ed yesterday from a business school professor calling for the abolishment of business schools. It sort of describes that business schools are very profit-oriented and train people that way that they can’t see anything else within profit. I was curious what you thought of that take on business schools and how everything in terms of systems and education sort of perpetrate systems of extraction.
Anya Kamenetz 33:54
I think that you know it’s not necessarily business schools themselves, but it’s the economic model that we’re preparing people to participate in, right? So, I’m sure you guys must be familiar with Kate Rayworth’s donut economics, but this is like an alternative viewpoint of economics that is really considering the health of people and planet at the same time, and not just about increasing GDP forever. So, I’m not against people going to school together to learn how to be more efficient or more effective or better leaders, but the problem is the underlying system that they’re preparing themselves for, right?
And it’s interesting. I actually did an in-depth report on Haas School of Business at Berkeley, and they have really made strides to try to embed sustainability within every level of their business school, and that has been a huge paradigm shift. Because when you are, you know, when you’re coaching people to really think about how does my business not only can it be sustainable, but could it even be regenerative and improve the model for everyone? I think it’s possible to do. So I think everything is reformable, even business schools. But what needs to be questioned is the underlying capitalism model.
Yeah, I’d love to hear Emily, Carolyn, Yadana, anything you got.
Emily Fano 35:09
Well, thanks for sharing that op-ed because my daughter wants to apply to business school, and I’m going to send her the op-ed right now. Yeah, I totally agree with you, Anya. About you know, it’s about what kind of society we’re grooming students to enter into or create, right? And what kind of values we’re inculcating with them with, when they are in school, and what kind of messages we’re telling them about what society is or could be, and you know the kind of thought that is allowed to flourish in these schools. Definitely, time for revolution and new ways of thinking across so many sectors of society, including academia. You know, especially academia.
Anya Kamenetz 36:03
Completely. And what do you think is the most important thing that needs to happen in order for that to take place within education?
Emily Fano 36:08
I mean, the kinds of you know, I think the kinds of things that we did in New York are really pushing policymakers and decision makers to change. I mean, we’re, you know this was in New York was a student-led effort, and students spoke. And look at what’s happening in France. I mean, people are rising up and demanding change. The systems that we have now are no longer serving, you know, what people believe is a just and sustainable future, a vision of that, and you know we have to demand more of our institutions. We have to push them to change. You know, I think that there’s been so many protests in so many parts of the world, and young people are really making those demands. I think more than anyone else. So we have to push our institutions to do better.
Anya Kamenetz 37:00
I completely agree with that, and I want to introduce the notion of sort of reverse mentorship. This is something we alluded to at the beginning of the call, but you know movements really do rely on young people because they don’t take the conditions for granted, right?
Many of us who have been around for a while have seen many dreams kind of face plant or or moments fade, but when you are in that first experience of seeing social change happen, being in that moment of a whirlwind, it’s so formative. And I think we need that energy. We need people to kind of pick it up and say, “This is our time,” and that is what we’re seeing with whether it’s like the Gen Z movement in Nepal or the Cockroach Party in India, or the protests also in there are some going on in Eastern Europe as well as in Belgrade as well as in France. So it’s always exciting to see that.
Catherine Du 37:52
On the topic of reverse mentorship, noting that a lot of the people here are women, I was curious if you think that fewer men are involved in the climate movement, and if so, why?
Anya Kamenetz 38:07
Yeah, this is such a huge issue. Oh my gosh! I mean, the concept that’s been coined to talk about this is petro masculinity, and that really is the notion that things to do with fossil fuels have become associated with the kind of sort of toxic masculinity, and that also includes eating beef, as well as driving big, enormous cars, as well as getting engaged in sort of extractive industries, which are which are very often associated with kind of a macho male behavior. Whether that’s like a logger, right? Like a lumberjack is probably like our biggest concept of what a masculine man could be. So you know, I think this is not a coincidence. I think that there is a close familial connection between capitalism, colonialism, and patriarchy. They are a system, and the system is a system of extraction and power over. And so it’s not incidental, and it can be daunting to realize that we’re fighting them all at the same time.
But the other thing to realize is that you don’t, you don’t fight them to win. I mean, what you realize is that the power, the other kind of power, which is power with, is a much deeper kind of power that’s existed since the beginning of the planet and since life has been born. And the matriarchal and horizontal and mycelial connection form of power has always been there too. And so it really is an issue of figuring out how we can grow and make that form of power even more visible. And to you know, I hope and I see that there are men who, yeah, I do. I think people are seeing through these types of messages and rejecting them. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think that well, I think that there are I think both are happening. I mean, there’s a political divide at the young male level. Although it is mostly determined from the numbers that I’ve seen in America, what you mostly see is that Gen Z women are getting more and more liberal. Not so much that Gen Z men are getting more and more right wing, but they are more and more disaffected. And so, you know, I believe in an everybody movement and figuring out how to involve and engage young men in seeing that these systems, patriarchy, capitalism, colonialism, they harm everybody.
Whatever your gender identity, whatever your relationship to masculinity, it’s harmful to live that way and to live at odds with the natural world. So, yeah, I think it’s a I think it’s a powerful connection. I don’t think it’s incidental, and I think that it requires a lot of discernment to help people see. “Okay, I don’t want to be a part of this anymore.” Just like how do you enlist white people, for example, to get involved in the cause of anti-racism, because they have to be able to look at themselves and say, “Okay, I’m a part of this, and I want to be part of the solution too.”
Catherine Du 41:09
In terms of jobs that people are involved in, it’s an interesting statistic where in every field of engineering except environmental engineering, the majority of people who take on that major are males, and the majority of people who take on environmental engineering are females. So I was curious why you think that like starts from the college level, and why you think that many students at like Hunter High School and like many other educational institutions are not that engaged in climate activism.
Anya Kamenetz 41:43
So, I mean, the answer to that question is twofold, right? So, first of all, we talked about how the climate problem feels daunting and overwhelming. So, there’s an aversion to getting engaged with it. People don’t always feel that sense of agency. But then the other part is the sort of hyper achievement culture, right? So, are people even feeling empowered to take on a job where you’re prioritizing a social mission over achievement that might be more recognized by society or materially recognized? Because maybe you’re coming to this school.
I mean, this is a public school. There’s kids in the school that you know they need to make a certain amount of money to feel like they can even stay in New York City, right? Be able to buy a house, get a job in the age of AI. So there’s real economic anxiety that comes from wanting to dream of a of a job that will get you some kind of security in a world that feels very uncertain. Yeah, I mean, I think I think that’s real. I think that’s to be understood and figuring out ways to allow people to dream of lives and lifestyles where they’re meaningful because they’re cooperative, and our sense of security actually comes from the relationships that we’re in and the type of future that we’re working towards building together. I think that’s you know that’s more than just an education question. That’s really a values question.
Catherine Du 43:01
I was curious, since you brought up AI, how you see artificial intelligence in the climate movement and in the global stage overall.
Anya Kamenetz 43:13
Yeah, absolutely. I just want to acknowledge what’s going on in the comments because I think there’s going to be an audio version of this, but we have the comment: connection is feeling like the groundwork for the new system.
I think it’s really applicable to AI because I think what AI is forcing us to consider is what is it that we, as living, breathing human beings uniquely have to offer to this world? And it turns out it’s not turning out product, right? It’s not about cogitating or researching or creating lots and lots of words and documents.
Even though I love doing those things and that’s what I apply myself to, what I’m going to be remembered for is the relationships that I had and my physical existence on this earth through the people that loved me and the people that know about my work. Hopefully, but hopefully they they get to know me as a person too through that work. So, yeah, I think that’s I think that’s ultimately a very good thing because I think that we’re overdue for that kind of consideration, right? Like, what is it that we have to offer? Are we just cogs in a machine? Are we just there to stamp out more and more and more product, or do we have something unique to offer? If the AI can do it for us, then probably it’s not the thing you want to be concentrating on doing.
Catherine Du 44:22
What do you see is the role of AI in the climate? Like aside from, I guess, like creating documents, do you think people should use it? Do you think people should abstain, or do you have another perspective?
Anya Kamenetz 44:35
I mean, first and foremost, what is exciting is that AI has brought a huge groundswell of opposition, and it has caused new coalitions to form across political divides, where people are working locally and nationally and internationally to stop data center infrastructure, to oppose AI in schools. I mean, the amount, the way that this is, and it’s really remarkable when you think about how much money the AI companies have given to dominate politics, but they haven’t won. I mean, they have completely lost in the court of public opinion in a very short period of time.
So it’s breathing new life into the climate movement. I was someone who was a little bit annoyed as I started hearing people talk about AI as an existential threat, and I was like, “Hey guys, we have an existential threat that we need to be paying attention to. This hypothetical one is actually not as important as this actual real one that’s happening.” But I learned I stopped worrying and learned to love the fact that people are excited about stopping AI, and what they really are excited about is stopping billionaires and stopping the takeover of their rural land and their water, and stopping the buildout of dirty fossil fuel energy infrastructure, and these are all ways to to oppose it. So, to me, the most exciting part of AI and the climate movement is the opposition that’s happening.
Catherine Du 45:55
Do you have anything else you’d like to add, or anything else you want us to know?
Anya Kamenetz 46:00
I mean, I’m just taking the question: Is there a community of writers and journalists who focus on these types of topics?
I’m not a part of a real climate journalism community. I’m a part of the climate mental health community, and I’m connected to a few people on LinkedIn and people on Grist. But that’s good to know about Kyle Pope. I don’t really know much about that. Yeah, and this comment that AI is not inevitable. I think that AI, I think AI as a technology is going to continue. The role that it plays in our lives is definitely not inevitable. Like right now, we’re in a wild west phase, and there’s very little regulation. There’s very little AI that’s being developed explicitly with the public interest in mind, but I don’t think the technology itself of LLMs is going away. But the form that it takes and the amount of regulation that’s definitely open to interpretation.
Catherine Du 46:52
Do you have any questions for the audience, me, or anyone else?
Anya Kamenetz 46:56
I mean, I’m happy for people to yeah speak up if you have other questions. And yeah, Catherine. I mean, what is it that you enjoy about doing this podcast?
Catherine Du 47:07
I think the most exciting part is hearing the diversity of experiences people have in working in the climate space. Like I know there are people who came from an academia lens. There’s people who come also from like mental health lens, like you do, and I feel like the diversity of ways to get involved in climate movement is very inspiring because it’s like you don’t have to be a climate scientist; you also don’t have to be like a specific like job in order to do something good for the world, which I think is very inspiring. I think it’s also interesting to learn more about like the facts,
Anya Kamenetz 47:46
yeah,
Catherine Du 47:47
…about climate change, like just from different people. Because I think getting news from only one source would be not great.
Anya Kamenetz 47:57
Yeah, yeah. I think that’s wonderful. I mean, I think in every field, not just in climate change, there is a dearth of connections between high school students and like real world world careers and working. So I’m excited for you that you found this space and that you know you’re able to be a part of it. And look how you’re in this conversation with teachers and really getting to have that two way learning experience. It’s really awesome to see.
Catherine Du 48:21
Thank you. I guess on a similar note, what sort of things do you rely on to learn about climate change and to like process, like I guess your emotions, sort of tie back to your outlook?
Anya Kamenetz 48:35
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, to learn about climate change, I follow a lot of Substacks, so I’m a big reader of Bill McKibben’s Substack, The Crucial Years. I also really recommend The Weekly Anthropocene. I’m going to drop the link in the chat, which is a compilation of good news, but not like it’s not superficial good news. It’s real stuff like species restoration and clean energy buildouts, and just like awesome things that are happening on a weekly basis.
I definitely like Emily Atkins. I follow everything that Amy Westervelt puts out, where she really is identifying the true villains in terms of corporate voices that have distorted the conversation on climate change for generations.
In terms of processing my emotions, I mean, I’ve been lucky enough to kind of create my own career around that. So I have Climate Mental Health Network. I have so many colleagues now in this space and friends in this space that I can turn to for climate realness. And I’ve become that person for others as well. So people come to me with their climate feelings, and so that’s something where I’m able to really see how we need more spaces for that kind of conversation, and I’m becoming more familiar with guiding people through it.
Carolyn: how do we talk with many climate youth activists? What drives their sense of agency to engage in activism? Because many students feel, yeah, defeated and cynical.
Yeah, I I know. I mean, this is so hard, right? Because I do get this question a lot, and I even I won’t say who it is, but I had a friend who was a very active in the climate space, and her child was very into cars as a as a hobby, and it was like the farthest thing that they could imagine from from the climate the climate cause or the climate crisis.
I think a sense of agency can be hard to find, and it’s honestly not just where, just not where every teenager is at this point in their lives. And it’s you know one thing that’s that’s fair to say is it can’t it can’t be instilled from the outside. So you know figuring out ways and opportunities for young people to feel successful in whatever it is that they’re doing, whether it’s academics or sports or a creative pursuit, I believe that that can carry over into other aspects of their lives, but you can’t really come to someone, and you can’t you can’t you can lead them to water, but you can’t make them drink when it comes to being a climate activist.
You know, and and I hope that I think that there’s the other part to it too is that it’s really natural to assume a polarity, right? So like if I’m expressing a lot of concern about climate. It’s very natural for the person talking to me to say, “Oh, it’s not that bad.” Whereas if I come out and say climate change doesn’t exist, that very same person might be like, “Oh no, I think there is a problem.” So sometimes we just find ourselves holding opposite ends of the pole. And if you’re coming in and saying like climate change is a really big problem, that it might be very like often for young people to say, well, we can’t do anything about it, and that learned helplessness also is something that’s coming from social media as well.
Underneath the defeat and the cynicism, I believe there’s a lot of brokenheartedness and there’s a lot of sense of loss, and so figuring out ways for for there to be a safe space to kind of get to those more tender feelings, and even to talk about what it is that we love about the natural world, the living world, our homes, that might be a little bit of a softer way in as well. You don’t have to move people immediately to action. It can be a very long chain of conversations before they feel like they can, like it’s safe for them to experience those feelings and be that they feel empowered to act on them.
Catherine Du 52:04
What do you think is like the hardest moment for a parent, and what should a parent expect if a child asks about climate change?
Anya Kamenetz 52:13
Well, it’s very hard having children these days when we don’t know what the world’s going to look like in 2045. So you know that that weighs on me, and I feel like my relationship with my kids has deepened through the work that I’ve done to try to come to terms with my own feelings, because I’ve learned that I don’t have all the answers.
I can’t have all the answers. Nobody holds the whole truth, and I know how I want to show up in the world. And the more that my kids can see me doing the work that I think is the most important, and to try to help other people, the more I think that first of all, they can be reassured that I’m working on it. That the adults are working on it. It’s not your job as kids to fix this. We, the adults, are the ones who made this problem happen. And they can say, “Oh, I can if my mom can do it, I can do it too.” So there’s a little bit of role modeling that can go on.
So I think it’s very normal in our house to, you know, do civic engagement and political stuff, and I see my 14-year-old doing it too. So I think that there’s, and I think also that there’s a sense that whatever is coming, that there is that we know we have a sort of a set of behaviors and attitudes that we’re going to bring to the challenge as a family.
Catherine Du 53:44
I was curious, from an educator’s perspective, what you think the hardest part about addressing climate change is, and how educators should face that.
Anya Kamenetz 53:54
I mean, we have educators on the call, but so if they have questions or thoughts about this, I’d love to hear them chime in. I think the number one blockage that I hear from educators is just that they feel that they don’t know enough about the problem, and that’s understandable because it’s very large and it’s outside any one particular person’s expertise. And then a close corollary of that is they feel that they don’t have the resources to deal with the feelings that come up when we’re teaching about this. Yeah, and that’s right. So also the idea that many still feel isolated. I hope that the growth of the mandate in New York State allows people to find community and to find trainings and other people that are engaged in this climate-based education, because I do think finding community is the crucial first step.
Emily Fano 54:48
I can add to that too that I mean, there’s been so many. I’ve been working on something that is about this very topic, and you know, from my perspective, the timetable, the timetable mismatch between the how long education takes for people to understand something and address it versus the accelerated breakdown that we’re seeing with the climate crisis and you know how things are moving really quickly, education doesn’t really move quickly, and the whole system is really built around siloed thematic areas.
So English, you learn English in one class. You learn, you know, and climate is a complex, extremely complex issue that you know involves so many different topics. And so the challenge I think for educators is that interdisciplinarity and learning how to get away from the siloed teaching that they’ve been trained to to you know, to deliver and understanding that they have to you know learn how to teach differently, and the whole education system is really not built for that. So the whole system has to change, and the way that education is conceived of and delivered has to be reimagined.
You know, and I think this new mandate is an opportunity to create that new understanding of what is really meaningful in education and how it really has to relate to people’s lived experiences, and really look at issues systemically and holistically rather than in silos. But obviously, the typical issues are teachers are feeling isolated. We talk about, you know, the lack of time, the lack of preparation, the lack of time to plan together. I mean, there’s just so many, you know, lack of funding. We, you know, this requirement is still not funded, and so it’s really an unfunded requirement at this time. So there’s just a lot of things that need to be addressed. But Yadana and others, please weigh in.
Yadana Desmond 56:42
I would add, hi Anya, hi Catherine. Sorry for being silent. I wasn’t sure what the protocol was, but I really appreciate you joining this amazing podcast. I think that in an interesting way, at least with the colleagues and nonprofits and teachers that we get a chance to work with, there is a kind of an opening, like the door being put ajar for, you know, sharing things that maybe you weren’t allowed to share before, projects you weren’t given, you know, accolades for before things that used to be like oh what is that project based thing that spans like eight weeks now it’s sort of like oh wait that’s an excellent case for this thing that that we’ve been talking about you know we see teachers who reach across to other classrooms and create these things and bring them to showcases, and you know, I ask the teachers, when did you do that? Oh, we did it in our lunch hour. I’m like, wait, what? You pulled, you know.
So, I think that there’s an understanding too, you know, you know, with the folks that we’re working with across New York State. I think there, this connection, we kind of understand that everything is going to be built on that. So it isn’t just single, you know, one-off connections. It’s this continuous coming back to listen again and again and again to like, how are things now? What are you learning now? What have you heard now? And I feel like this is really kind of this initial fabric knitting of the new system that is happening that we’re kind of a part of.
Anya Kamenetz 58:30
I love that you know, and I mean it’s really inspiring to watch. First of all, and secondly, you know, coming from a background of covering innovation and education for the last 20 years, it strikes me that the moves that need to be made in order to teach climate well are the same things we need to do for education. Full stop, right? So we need to have a human centered approach. We need to come out of silos. We need to have project based learning. We need to create learning that is relevant and applicable to students’ futures. We need to combine, you know, different disciplines together, and so it’s kind of like with climate change, with society as a whole, right? It’s like all of these changes would need to be made, even if climate wasn’t happening, and it’s a very daunting challenge. But also, the solutions stack very well together.